An R Companion for the Handbook of Biological Statistics

Salvatore S. Mangiafico

Search Rcompanion.org

Contrasts in Linear Models

Contrasts can be used to make specific comparisons of treatments within a linear model.

One common use is when a factorial design is used, but control or check treatments are used in addition to the factorial design.  In the first example below, there are two treatments (D and C) each at two levels (1 and 2), and then there is a Control treatment. The approach used here is to analyze the experiment as a one-way analysis of variance, and then use contrasts to test various hypotheses.

Another common use is when there are several treatments that could be thought of as members of a group.  In the second example below,  there are measurements for six wines, some of which are red (Merlot, Cabernet, Syrah) and some of which are white (Chardonnay, Riesling, Gewürztraminer).  We can compare the treatments within the red wine group by setting up contrasts and conducting an F-test.  This is analogous to testing the main effect of Red Wine.

The packages lsmeans and multcomp allow for unlimited tests of single-degree contrasts, with a p-value correction for multiple tests.  They also allow for an F-test for multi-line contrasts, for example when testing within groups.  The aov function in the native stats package has more limited functionality.

See the chapters on One-way Anova and Two-way Anova for general considerations on conducting analysis of variance

Packages used in this chapter

The following commands will install these packages if they are not already installed:

if(!require(car)){install.packages("car")}
if(!require(lsmeans){install.packages("lsmeans")}
if(!require(multcomp)){install.packages("multcomp")}

Example for single degree-of-freedom contrasts

This hypothetical example could represent an experiment with a factorial design two treatments (D and C) each at two levels (1 and 2), and a control treatment.  The 2-by-2 factorial plus control is treated as a one-way anova with five treatments.

Input = ("
Treatment   Response
 'D1:C1'    1.0
 'D1:C1'    1.2
 'D1:C1'    1.3
 'D1:C2'    2.1
 'D1:C2'    2.2
 'D1:C2'    2.3
 'D2:C1'    1.4
 'D2:C1'    1.6
 'D2:C1'    1.7
 'D2:C2'    2.5
 'D2:C2'    2.6
 'D2:C2'    2.8
 'Control'  1.0
 'Control'  0.9
 'Control'  0.8
")

Data = read.table(textConnection(Input),header=TRUE)


### Specify the order of factor levels. Otherwise R will alphabetize them.

Data$Treatment = factor(Data$Treatment,
                        levels=unique(Data$Treatment))

Data

boxplot(Response ~ Treatment,
        data = Data,
        ylab="Response",
        xlab="Treatment")

###  Define linear model

model = lm(Response ~ Treatment,
           data = Data)

library(car)

Anova(model, type="II")

summary(model)

Example with lsmeans

###  You need to look at order of factor levels to determine the contrasts

levels(Data$Treatment)     

[1] "D1:C1"   "D1:C2"   "D2:C1"   "D2:C2"   "Control"

library(lsmeans)

leastsquare = lsmeans(model, "Treatment")

Contrasts = list(D1vsD2          = c(1,  1, -1, -1,  0),
                 C1vsC2          = c(1, -1,  1, -1,  0),
                 InteractionDC   = c(1, -1, -1,  1,  0),
                 C1vsC2forD1only = c(1, -1,  0,  0,  0),
                 C1vsC2forD2only = c(0,  0,  1, -1,  0),
                 TreatsvsControl = c(1,  1,  1,  1, -4),
                 T1vsC           = c(1,  0,  0,  0, -1),
                 T2vsC           = c(0,  1,  0,  0, -1),
                 T3vsC           = c(0,  0,  1,  0, -1),
                 T4vsC           = c(0,  0,  0,  1, -1))

   ### The column names match the order of levels of the treatment variable
   ### The coefficients of each row sum to 0

contrast(leastsquare, Contrasts, adjust="sidak")

 contrast           estimate        SE df t.ratio p.value
 D1vsD2          -0.83333333 0.1549193 10  -5.379  0.0031
 C1vsC2          -2.10000000 0.1549193 10 -13.555  <.0001
 InteractionDC    0.03333333 0.1549193 10   0.215  1.0000
 C1vsC2forD1only -1.03333333 0.1095445 10  -9.433  <.0001
 C1vsC2forD2only -1.06666667 0.1095445 10  -9.737  <.0001
 TreatsvsControl  3.96666667 0.3464102 10  11.451  <.0001
 T1vsC            0.26666667 0.1095445 10   2.434  0.3011
 T2vsC            1.30000000 0.1095445 10  11.867  <.0001
 T3vsC            0.66666667 0.1095445 10   6.086  0.0012
 T4vsC            1.73333333 0.1095445 10  15.823  <.0001

   ### Note that p-values are slightly different than those from multcomp
   ###  due to different adjustment methods.  If “none” is chosen as
   ###  the adjustment method for both procedures,
   ###  p-values and other statistics will be the same.

   ### With adjust="none", results will be the same as
   ###   the aov method.

Example with multcomp

###  You need to look at order of factor levels to determine the contrasts

levels(Data$Treatment)     

[1] "D1:C1"   "D1:C2"   "D2:C1"   "D2:C2"   "Control"

Input = ("
Contrast.Name     D1C2  D1C2 D2C1 D2C2  Control
 D1vsD2            1     1   -1   -1     0
 C1vsC2            1    -1    1   -1     0
 InteractionDC     1    -1   -1    1     0
 C1vsC2forD1only   1    -1    0    0     0
 C1vsC2forD2only   0     0    1   -1     0
 TreatsvsControl   1     1    1    1    -4
 T1vsC             1     0    0    0    -1
 T2vsC             0     1    0    0    -1
 T3vsC             0     0    1    0    -1
 T4vsC             0     0    0    1    -1
")

   ### The column names match the order of levels of the treatment variable
   ### The coefficients of each row sum to 0

Matriz = as.matrix(read.table(textConnection(Input),
                   header=TRUE,
                   row.names=1))

Matriz


library(multcomp)

G = glht(model,
         linfct = mcp(Treatment = Matriz))

G$linfct

summary(G,
        test=adjusted("single-step"))

   ### Adjustment options: "none", "single-step", "Shaffer",
   ###                     "Westfall", "free", "holm", "hochberg",
   ###                     "hommel", "bonferroni", "BH", "BY", "fdr"

                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)   

D1vsD2 == 0          -0.83333    0.15492  -5.379  0.00218 **

C1vsC2 == 0          -2.10000    0.15492 -13.555  < 0.001 ***

InteractionDC == 0    0.03333    0.15492   0.215  0.99938   

C1vsC2forD1only == 0 -1.03333    0.10954  -9.433  < 0.001 ***

C1vsC2forD2only == 0 -1.06667    0.10954  -9.737  < 0.001 ***

TreatsvsControl == 0  3.96667    0.34641  11.451  < 0.001 ***

T1vsC == 0            0.26667    0.10954   2.434  0.17428   

T2vsC == 0            1.30000    0.10954  11.867  < 0.001 ***

T3vsC == 0            0.66667    0.10954   6.086  < 0.001 ***

T4vsC == 0            1.73333    0.10954  15.823  < 0.001 ***

### With test=adjusted("none"), results will be the same as aov method below.

#     #     #

Example for global F-test within a group of treatments

This example has treatments consisting of three red wines and three white wines.  We will want to know if there is an effect of the treatments in the red wine group on the response variable, while keeping the individual identities of the wines in the Treatment variable.  This approach is advantageous because post-hoc comparisons could still be made within the red wines, for example comparing Merlot to Cabernet.

Input = ("
Treatment          Response
 Merlot             5
 Merlot             6
 Merlot             7
 Cabernet           8
 Cabernet           9
 Cabernet          10
 Syrah             11
 Syrah             12
 Syrah             13

 Chardonnay         1
 Chardonnay         2
 Chardonnay         3
 Riesling           1
 Riesling           2
 Riesling           2
 Gewürtztraminer    1
 Gewürtztraminer    2
 Gewürtztraminer    4
")

Data = read.table(textConnection(Input),header=TRUE)


### Specify the order of factor levels. Otherwise R will alphabetize them.

Data$Treatment = factor(Data$Treatment,
                        levels=unique(Data$Treatment))

Data

boxplot(Response ~ Treatment,
        data = Data,
        ylab="Response",
        xlab="Treatment")

©2015 by Salvatore S. Mangiafico.
Rutgers Cooperative Extension, New Brunswick, NJ.

Organization of statistical tests and selection of examples for these tests ©2014 by John H. McDonald.  Used with permission.

Non-commercial reproduction of this content, with attribution, is permitted.  For-profit reproduction without permission is prohibited.

If you use the code or information in this site in a published work, please cite it as a source.  Also, if you are an instructor and use this book in your course, please let me know.   My contact information is on the About the Author page.

This site uses advertising from Media.net. For more information, visit our privacy policy page.  Proceeds from these ads go to support education and research activities, including the improvement of this site.

Citation:

Mangiafico, S.S. 2015. An R Companion for the Handbook of Biological Statistics, version 1.3.2.
rcompanion.org/rcompanion/. (Pdf version: rcompanion.org/documents/RCompanionBioStatistics.pdf.)